Welcome to Dough Boy's Pizza
Dough Boy's Pizza, located at 1207 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI, is a hidden gem celebrated for its diverse pizza offerings and exceptional crusts. Known for their impressive thick and deep-dish styles, each slice is hearty and bursting with toppings. Customers rave about the perfectly cooked pepperoni and the delightful crunch of the crust, often labeled the star of the show. The menu caters to all preferences, from thin crust to unique French bread pizzas, ensuring there's something for everyone. The warm and welcoming staff further enhances the experience, making Dough Boy's a must-visit for pizza lovers in Madison.
Dough Boy's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
I got 2 slices of pepperoni and sausage (from the warmer). 13 for 2 slices plus you get a free drink when you buy 2 slices. Pizza is very thick and very heavy so you definitely get your money's worth. The pizza is good, and just as the name would suggest, the crust is where this pizza shines. I absolutely love the thick "burnt" crusty part around the edge, it really pulls the pizza together imo. The pepperoni was cooked perfectly, cooked to a crunch but not burnt. My only complaint is, I am a sauce heavy type of person, and this was lacking slightly. However the pizza is good enough it doesn't even matter. Maybe next time I'll get a little sauce on the side to dip it in. The person working the register who waited on me was very friendly as well so 1 for that Can't wait to try the rest of the menu now
My buddy and I have been talking about trying Dough Boy's for over a month now after seeing a number of posts on the Madison Foodie site. We weren't sure what to expect based on some fairly negative reviews but we also saw several positive reviews so decided to give it a try. We went in a bit skeptical with low expectations. We ordered a thin crust pizza with sausage and mushroom and took some pan style sausage and pepperoni slices to go as well. I'm normally a thin crust pizza fan over pan style. The slices were huge. 7.25 for 2 slices or 4 for one. One slice is probably enough for most people and was in our case. That's saying a lot :) Lots of toppings and cheese. It was delicious. The thin crust was very good and I thought the price was very reasonable considering prices today. I have to say the pan style was my favorite. I took the thin crust home and my wife who normally likes pan style absolutely loved the thin crust. We will definitely be back to carry out again.
They were nice enough to deliver outside of their delivery radius and my pizza was still hot and super fresh. I love the flavor of the sauce and their ranch is also really good!
Talked with the manager today, who was extremely pleasant. Got a few slices to go. Had never had the plain cheese slice here before and it was AWESOME and also gone before I got to my house. Dough Boys: Please stay open a long, long time. Locals: this is the place I was looking for, so please give them your patronage, don’t screw this up for me!
Tried three different pizza styles - deep dish, thin crust, and french bread. Impossible to pick a favorite, all of them were delicious.
My first time in Madison visiting friends. They suggested we try this place out and I was not disappointed. I would say this is a must pizza place to visit when visiting the area. Food was amazing and I loved the deep dish. All of the food was really tasty and hit the spot. I would not hesitate to go again next time I am in town.
I'd seen a few posts about Doughboys Pizza. We were looking for a real Deep dish Chicago pizza, and we found it! It was awesome, done on time cooked perfectly, so thick, the box would close flat!! 12" will feed 4-5 easily! It's just a carry-out place in a strip mall, But the pizza was top notch!
They got us this pizza at work, and I'm hooked. 5 or 6 pizzas from here. It's delicious! Plenty of excellent cheese and toppings and no huge, wasted crust around the edges. The delicious went all the way to the outer perimeter of the pie. There's some really, really good pizza in Madison, and this is right up among the very best with its own unique style. Like I said, it isn't surrounded by bread. The edge is just like a little bit more crunchy cheese! That's the way ya do it.
Location
-
1207 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI 53704, United States Hotline: +1 608-467-3017
Welcome to the delicious world of Dough Boy's Pizza, a vibrant culinary gem located at 1207 N Sherman Ave in Madison, WI. Known for their robust and hearty pizzas, Dough Boy's has become a community favorite, creating a buzz among foodies eager to sample their diverse offerings.
The essence of Dough Boy's lies in their pizza, where every slice represents a balance of quality and flavor. Customers rave about their thick, decadent crust that adds a delightful texture to each bite. As one enthusiastic diner, Robbie H, noted, the "burnt" crusty edge is the perfect complement to the toppings, making each slice a hearty meal. This attention to crust quality sets them apart from the average pizza joint, ensuring that diners receive more than just your typical pizza experience.
Dough Boy's menu is a playground for pizza lovers. Whether you prefer a thin crust loaded with toppings, like the sausage and mushroom combination praised by Mike Reimer, or the rich and satisfying pan style that leaves you yearning for more, there's a style for everyone. Jess Draws highlights the variety, affirming that every option, from deep dish to French bread, offers a unique and delightful adventure for your taste buds.
Not only do they excel in delivering fantastic pizza, but they also ensure a pleasant and welcoming experience. Customers frequently mention the friendly staff, with Nate Mendl noting the pleasant conversation with the manager, which adds a personal touch to every visit. It’s this combination of great food and a warm atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back for more, fostering a sense of community around pizza.
Finally, let’s not forget the sauce! While some diners like Robbie H expressed a desire for more of it, the overall flavor balance still captivates the palate, making it easy to overlook any minor setbacks. You might even want to grab some during your next visit for dipping—who wouldn’t enjoy that? And for those wondering about delivery, Haley Watters shared her joy about receiving hot, fresh pizza right to her door, even outside the standard delivery radius—a testament to Dough Boy's commitment to great service.
With rave reviews highlighting not only the delicious pizzas but also the experience and friendliness at Dough Boy's Pizza, it's clear that this establishment is worth the visit. Whether you're a lifelong local or just passing through Madison, Dough Boy's promises memories that are not just about eating, but savoring the moments shared over great pizza. Don't miss out on this culinary delight; stop by and see for yourself!